Goodbye Carly

I found tonight's American Idol to be completely shocking. I never in a million years thought that Carly Smithson would go home. I didn't think she would win the whole show but I certainly didn't think tonight was her night to go packing. I chose Jason Castro and Brooke White for the bottom two and neither of them were! The bottom two tonight were Carly Smithson and Syesha Mercado. I didn't want Brooke White to be in the bottom two but I thought for sure she would be because of her screw up last night BUT I think that screw up may have saved her. I think people actually didn't mind the fact that she screwed up. Simon also said tonight that it showed that she was human and people like that.

But Jason Castro!? Come on now! The judges didn't like his performance, Andrew Lloyd Webber didn't like his performance, the posts I read on the internet didn't like his performance so I am wondering where his votes came from. Im starting to think he has a huge teeny bopper fan base. I think its sad Carly Smithson went home because she is extremely talented but I think she will go far after the show is over.